August 21, 2023
With touching sensitivity, Sullivan (Stanley’s Secret) creates a story about a child responsibly caring for stray felines. Each day on his walk to school with big brother Sam, Ethan encounters three kittens living in an alley. Yearning for a pet in a “no pets” household, Ethan names the kittens and discerns three distinct personalities: black and white Fluffy is curious, gray Misty is shy, and tiny tabby Dusty is bold. Ethan feeds them from his lunch box and worries about how they’ll stay warm in blustery, snowy weather, and with Sam’s assistance—the depth of their connection is one of the story’s quiet delights—joins the trap-neuter-return movement. Mixed-media cartoon art by Aly (Salat in Secret), which portrays the siblings with brown skin, walk readers through Ethan’s growing understanding of the kittens’ situation, tempering the tale’s instructional aspects with irresistible characterizations. Ethan’s bright eyes reflect a serious eagerness, and Sam exudes pragmatism and patience in a book that offers an affectionately realized vision of what one kid can do. An afterword concludes. Ages 4–8.
September 15, 2023
Ethan and his older brother, Sam, are walking to school on a city street when Ethan notices several stray cats. Ethan asks Sam if he thinks their father would allow them to get a pet cat. Sam attempts to dissuade him ("These cats aren't pets"), but Ethan can't stop thinking about them. He stops by to see them and gives them names. "Misty is curious, Fluffy is shy, and the littlest, Dusty, is bold." When the boys visit the library, Ethan learns about cats' needs and later notices a sign outside the animal clinic: "TRAP NEUTER RETURN." Sam explains that neuter means preventing cats from having kittens, and the boys enter the clinic. They leave with three humane traps, entice the cats with tuna, and accompany them to the clinic to ensure that the strays will not bring new kittens into the world. Although the information on trap-neuter-return in the backmatter instructs readers to ask clinics about volunteers who might assist them, the boys carry out the mission by themselves. Adults--such as the vet and the boys' father--are mentioned, but none appear in the cartoonish, mixed-media illustrations. Though the subject matter is appealing, the didactic, purposeful text likely won't interest most readers. The brothers have dark brown skin and curly hair. A worthy message about managing the population of street cats marred by flat writing. (resources) (Picture book. 6-8)
COPYRIGHT(2023) Kirkus Reviews, ALL RIGHTS RESERVED.
Starred review from October 1, 2023
PreS-Gr 2-Ethan, a young boy with dark skin and curly hair, walks to school with his older brother, Sam, as three curious kittens scamper from a shadowy alley. Ethan wonders aloud if they could bring one home and Sam reminds him that their father said no pets, encouraging him not to get attached. Empathetic Ethan cannot ignore his concern for the vulnerable kittens, so the brothers visit the litter each day offering lunchbox scraps. Passing the local animal clinic, the brothers read a sign: "Trap-Neuter-Return." Ethan is empowered to do more than offer the kittens food after learning that neutering strays contributes to fewer hungry cats on city streets. All the while, Ethan shelters the hope that he will not have to part with the smallest and boldest kitten. Sullivan's outstanding story and Aly's warm, expressive mixed media illustrations seamlessly unite to offer an age-appropriate look at what can be done to address the cyclical issue of stray animals. Back matter includes additional resources as well as detailed steps on how to trap, neuter, and return homeless cats. VERDICT A demonstration of individual responsibility, this loving and conscientious story deserves a home in all library collections.-Emily Brush
Copyright 2023 School Library Journal, LLC Used with permission.
October 31, 2023
Grades K-3 Every day on their way to and from school, Ethan and his older brother, Sam, pass three stray cats. Ethan would desperately love to keep one, but Dad says no pets. As the weather grows colder, Ethan worries about how they will stay warm and fed. He brings them his leftovers, and Sam buys outdoor cat shelters from a veterinary clinic, where the boys take the cats to be spayed and neutered before re-releasing them. Will Dad change his mind on the no-pets policy? The mixed-media artwork is colorful, the protagonist is adorably cherubic, and it is a positive representation of two brothers of color working together on a project in a sweet, collaborative way. While the story may be thin, it's a solid, fact-filled book for kiddos curious about cat care, incorporating information about how cat fur grows thicker in winter, how you can calm a cat by draping a blanket over its cage, and how insulated boxes provide shelter for strays. Thoughtful back matter includes resources and tips on how to catch-neuter/spay-return a cat.
COPYRIGHT(2023) Booklist, ALL RIGHTS RESERVED.